Yesterday, after months of making pizza, we finally “invested” $20 in a pizza stone. You’re supposed to stick the stone in a cold oven at least 30 minutes beforehand and warm up the oven to temperatures of 450-500. It was a little bit of an adventure getting the pizza from the cutting board to the searing hot stone without a pizza paddle, but we managed it by wearing oven mitts, pulling out the rack with the stone on it a little, and by covering the cutting board with enough cornmeal to help the pizza slide off relatively easily.
3 cups unbleached all purpose flour or bread flour, chilled (I put mine in the freezer for about 15 minutes)
2 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon instant yeast
1 ¼ cup ice cold water (I put it in the freezer for a few minutes and pulled it out before it solidified)
¼ cup olive oil
A couple of handfuls of cornmeal for dusting
The night before:
1) Stir together flour, salt, and instant yeast in large bowl.
2) Add water and oil slowly and stir in with a large metal spoon.
3) Work the dough with your hands. Mix and knead it together, and you can work the spoon like a dough hook by smoothing the dough with the spoon in one hand and by turning the bowl with your other hand in the opposite direction. Keep kneading the dough by turning and smoothing and kneading it into a disc then folding and shaping into a large ball.
4) Sprinkle flour on a cutting board or country and place the ball of dough on it. Separate the dough in two and sprinkle flour over both sections and shape them into 2 round smooth balls. If they’re sticky, add more flour. Cover both balls of dough with a little bit of dough and place in fridge, covered (I used ziplock bags). The dough will keep in the fridge for three days or in a freezer bag for longer.
The day of:
1) About 2 hours before cooking, pull out a dough ball (or both, if desired) and let rest for an hour under loose plastic wrap or a tea towel.
2) After 1 hour, work the dough into a disc with your hands. Sprinkle with flour, then a little oil, then a little flour, then a little oil (while working it).
3) Spread a lot of cornmeal on a cutting board or the back side of a baking sheet and place the dough on it. The bottom of the pizza should be covered in cornmeal.
4) Using a rolling pin, spread out your dough into a pizza size. It can be irregular, it just adds to the charm. Punch down some little finger holes. The dough can be very thin but cannot be translucent or have holes. Leave it to rest again.
5) Place pizza stone in middle rack of cold oven and preheat oven to 450 or 500 for 45 minutes.
6) Brush crust with garlic and salted olive oil and work some minced garlic into the edges of the crust.
7) Add tomato sauce, toppings, herbs and cheese, leaving space at the edges for the crust.
8) Using oven mitts, pull out the oven rack a little and slide the pizza very gently from the cutting board to the stone. Some people use parchment paper, but we found it easier to just use a ton of cornmeal under the pizza to help it slide.
9) After 2 minutes, take a peek to see if the pizza needs to be rotated 180 degrees. The pizza takes about 5-8 minutes to bake, but keep an eye on it due to the high temperature. Ours was done in about 6 minutes.
10) When finished, pull out the oven rack with oven mitts, and slide the pizza back onto the cutting board from the pizza stone.
11) Cool for a few minutes, slice, and eat.